Skin Pinch Blepharoplasty: Does It Treat Crepey Skin and Under-Eye Wrinkles?
“Skin pinch” has become something of a buzzword in aesthetic surgery.
More and more patients, including increasingly younger patients, are coming to our San Diego practice asking specifically for a lower eyelid skin pinch. A common request sounds something like: “I have crepey skin under my eyes.” Or: “I get all these wrinkles under my eyes when I smile. Can you just remove some of the skin?”
The assumption seems logical. If there are wrinkles and there appears to be “extra” skin, removing some of that skin should make everything tighter and smoother. But that assumption overlooks an important distinction.
A skin pinch treats excess skin. It does not necessarily treat poor skin quality, and it does not eliminate the dynamic wrinkles that appear when you smile.
Understanding the difference between skin quantity, skin quality, and dynamic wrinkles is essential before considering lower eyelid surgery.
What Is Skin Pinch Blepharoplasty?
A skin pinch blepharoplasty is a surgical technique in which a carefully measured amount of lower eyelid skin is removed through an incision typically positioned just beneath the eyelashes.
When performed for the appropriate indication, it can be a useful component of lower eyelid blepharoplasty. The key indication is true excess skin.
A skin pinch should not simply be viewed as a treatment for any wrinkle that happens to be located beneath the eye. That distinction is particularly important as more young patients request the procedure specifically to treat crepey skin or wrinkles when smiling.
The Biggest Misconception: Skin Pinch Treats Crepey Skin
One of the most common misconceptions I hear is that removing lower eyelid skin will improve the quality of the remaining skin. It doesn't.
If the skin beneath your eyes is thin, crepey, sun damaged, or has lost some of its elasticity, removing a strip of that skin does not fundamentally change the characteristics of the skin that remains. You simply have less of the same skin.
This is the difference between skin quantity and skin quality.
Skin quantity means excess skin
This refers to genuine skin redundancy. There is physically more skin than is needed to comfortably cover the lower eyelid in its normal position.
Skin quality means the condition of the skin
This includes:
Crepey texture
Fine lines
Sun damage
Loss of elasticity
Collagen loss
Uneven pigmentation
Surface irregularities
A skin pinch can reduce skin quantity. It does not directly improve skin quality.
Hemming Your Pants Doesn't Iron Out the Wrinkles
I sometimes explain this distinction with a simple analogy. Imagine you have a pair of pants with wrinkles in the fabric. You could shorten those pants by removing a few inches and hemming them. The pants would now contain less fabric. But would the remaining fabric suddenly be smooth? No.
Hemming your pants doesn't iron out the wrinkles.
The same concept applies to lower eyelid skin. Removing some skin may reduce the amount of skin present, but it does not inherently improve the texture or biological quality of the skin that remains.
If your primary problem is crepey skin, the better question may not be “How much skin can we remove?” It may be “How can we improve the skin itself?”
Why Do Under-Eye Wrinkles Appear When You Smile?
A patient looks into the mirror with a relaxed face and the lower eyelids look relatively smooth. Then they smile and suddenly multiple wrinkles appear beneath and beside the eyes. The immediate reaction is often: “Look at all this extra skin.”
But those wrinkles do not necessarily represent excess skin. They are often dynamic wrinkles.
When you smile, the muscles surrounding the eyes contract. In particular, the orbicularis oculi muscle contracts and naturally folds the overlying skin. That movement is part of normal facial expression.
If the wrinkles appear primarily when you smile but largely disappear when your face is relaxed, surgically removing skin is generally not addressing the underlying cause. The underlying cause is movement.
A Skin Pinch Does Not Stop Dynamic Wrinkles
A skin pinch does not stop the muscles around your eyes from contracting when you smile.
After skin is removed, the remaining skin still sits over a moving muscle. When that muscle contracts, the skin will continue to fold.
Trying to surgically eliminate every wrinkle that appears during facial expression would require removing an inappropriate amount of skin and could jeopardize the normal position and function of the lower eyelid.
A natural-looking face should also move. The goal of eyelid rejuvenation should not be to create a lower eyelid that remains unnaturally smooth regardless of expression.
Botox for Wrinkles When Smiling
When wrinkles are predominantly dynamic, meaning they appear or become substantially more noticeable with smiling or squinting, treatment aimed at the underlying muscle activity may be more appropriate.
This is where Botox or another neuromodulator may be useful. Botox works by temporarily reducing the strength of selected muscle contractions. Around the eyes, carefully placed treatment can soften dynamic lines associated with smiling and squinting.
The distinction is straightforward:
Excess skin: consider skin removal.
Poor skin quality and crepiness: consider resurfacing.
Wrinkles caused by facial movement: consider Botox.
Of course, many patients have some combination of all three, which is why an individualized examination is important.
What Actually Treats Crepey Under-Eye Skin?
If the problem is skin quality, treatment should be directed toward improving skin quality. One of my preferred options for appropriately selected patients is CO₂ laser resurfacing.
Unlike a skin pinch, which physically removes a portion of skin, CO₂ laser resurfacing is designed to remodel the skin itself. Controlled laser energy stimulates a healing response and collagen remodeling, which can improve:
Fine lines
Crepey texture
Sun-damaged skin
Skin smoothness
Texture
Overall skin quality
For a younger patient with good lower eyelid position, minimal true skin excess, and primarily crepey skin, resurfacing may make considerably more sense than surgically removing healthy lower eyelid skin.
Sometimes the Best Treatment Is a Combination
Lower eyelid aging rarely falls perfectly into a single category. A patient may have mild skin redundancy and crepey skin. Another may have under-eye bags, tear trough hollows, and dynamic wrinkles when smiling. An older patient may have all of the above.
Rather than expecting one procedure to solve every concern, we can match each treatment to the problem it is designed to address.
True excess skin: a conservative skin pinch may be appropriate.
Crepey texture and fine lines at rest: CO₂ laser resurfacing may improve skin quality.
Wrinkles primarily with smiling or squinting: Botox or another neuromodulator may help soften the muscular component.
Under-eye bags and tear trough hollows: lower eyelid blepharoplasty with fat repositioning may be considered.
Loss of facial or midface volume: volume restoration, including fat grafting in appropriately selected patients, may be considered.
Sometimes one treatment is enough. Sometimes a carefully planned combination produces the most natural result.
Why Are More Young Patients Requesting Skin Pinch Surgery?
Social media has dramatically changed how patients learn about cosmetic procedures. Terms that were once primarily used between surgeons are now consumer-facing buzzwords. “Skin pinch” is increasingly discussed online as though it were a simple way to tighten the lower eyelids or eliminate under-eye wrinkles.
As a result, I am seeing more patients in their 20s, 30s, and 40s specifically asking for skin removal.
But the ability to physically pinch skin between two fingers does not mean that skin is truly excessive. Skin needs some mobility. And the presence of wrinkles does not automatically mean there is too much skin. This is especially true when those wrinkles appear primarily during smiling.
Who Is a Candidate for a Skin Pinch?
In my practice, lower eyelid skin removal is generally reserved for patients with true skin redundancy. This is more commonly encountered in older patients as part of the natural aging process.
Age itself is not an absolute criterion, but younger patients are less likely to have the degree of genuine skin excess that warrants surgical removal.
Before recommending a skin pinch, I evaluate:
True lower eyelid skin redundancy
Lower eyelid tone
Eyelid position
Eye prominence
Midface and cheek support
Skin elasticity
Skin texture
Under-eye fat
Tear trough anatomy
Previous eyelid surgery
Ocular surface health
The important question is not: “Can some skin be removed?” Technically, skin can almost always be removed. The better question is: “Does skin need to be removed, and can it be removed without compromising the eyelid?”
Removing Lower Eyelid Skin Is Not Risk-Free
The lower eyelid is a delicate anatomical structure. Removing skin can create vertical tension on the eyelid. In an appropriately selected patient, conservative skin removal may be well tolerated.
In the wrong patient, or when too much skin is removed, that tension can contribute to lower eyelid malposition. Potential changes can include:
Lower eyelid retraction
Increased scleral show
Rounding of the eye
Ectropion
An unnatural or “operated” appearance
These problems may become apparent relatively soon after surgery. But there is another issue that deserves consideration: the face continues to age.
What Happens to a Skin Pinch as You Get Older?
Cosmetic surgery does not freeze the face in time. As we age, the cheek and midface gradually descend. The support structures surrounding the lower eyelid also change.
That means the forces acting on your lower eyelid at age 35 will not necessarily be the same at age 55 or 65.
If lower eyelid skin was unnecessarily or aggressively removed when someone was young, there may be less skin reserve available as the midface descends with age. In some patients, lower eyelid malposition may therefore become apparent not only immediately after surgery, but potentially years later as the face continues to age.
This is one reason I am particularly cautious about removing lower eyelid skin from younger patients. When considering surgery at 35, we should not think only about what the eyelid will look like six months later. We should also consider what we are leaving behind for the 45-, 55-, and 65-year-old version of that patient.
Do You Need a Skin Pinch With Lower Blepharoplasty?
No. Lower eyelid blepharoplasty does not automatically require skin removal.
For many patients with under-eye bags but good skin elasticity and little true skin excess, lower eyelid surgery can be performed through a transconjunctival approach, with the incision hidden inside the eyelid. Lower eyelid fat can then be addressed or repositioned without removing external skin.
If skin quality is also a concern, CO₂ laser resurfacing may be considered. If dynamic wrinkles are bothersome, Botox may be considered. If true skin redundancy exists, then conservative skin removal may have a role.
Each problem deserves its own solution.
A Better Way to Think About Under-Eye Wrinkles
Rather than looking in the mirror and asking, “Do I need a skin pinch?”, I encourage patients to identify when and why the wrinkles appear.
If you see wrinkles at rest, look at the quality of the skin. If the skin looks thin and crepey, think about skin quality and resurfacing.
If wrinkles appear predominantly when you smile, think about muscle movement and dynamic wrinkles.
If there is genuine skin hanging or folding even when the face is relaxed, then there may be true skin redundancy.
And if the primary concern is a bag or hollow beneath the eye, the problem may have relatively little to do with the skin at all. This is why the diagnosis matters more than the name of the procedure.
Skin Pinch Blepharoplasty in San Diego: Treat the Problem, Not the Trend
“Skin pinch” may be trending, but lower eyelid anatomy has not changed.
For an appropriately selected patient with genuine excess skin, conservative skin removal can be an effective part of lower eyelid blepharoplasty. But it is not a universal treatment for under-eye wrinkles. It does not inherently improve crepey skin. It does not stop dynamic wrinkles when you smile. And not everyone has enough true skin redundancy to justify removing lower eyelid skin.
At Oculofacial Surgical Arts in San Diego, Jean-Paul Abboud, MD, PhD takes a conservative, anatomy-driven approach to lower eyelid rejuvenation. The objective is not simply to make the eyelid as tight as possible. It is to identify what is actually causing the patient's concern and select a treatment that addresses that specific problem while preserving the long-term structure, function, and natural appearance of the eyelid.
Sometimes that means a skin pinch. Sometimes it means CO₂ laser resurfacing. Sometimes it means Botox. Sometimes it means lower eyelid blepharoplasty with fat repositioning. And sometimes the best thing we can do for the lower eyelid is not remove any skin at all.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a skin pinch get rid of the wrinkles under my eyes when I smile?
Not necessarily. Wrinkles that appear primarily when smiling are often dynamic wrinkles created by contraction of the muscles around the eye. Removing skin does not stop those muscles from moving. Botox or another neuromodulator may be more appropriate for the dynamic component.
Does skin pinch blepharoplasty treat crepey under-eye skin?
A skin pinch removes excess skin. It does not inherently improve the quality of the skin that remains. When crepey texture and fine lines are the primary concern, treatments such as CO₂ laser resurfacing may be more appropriate.
What is better for under-eye wrinkles: Botox, CO₂ laser, or skin pinch?
It depends on what is causing the wrinkles. Botox primarily addresses dynamic wrinkles related to muscle movement. CO₂ laser resurfacing addresses skin quality, texture, and fine lines. A skin pinch addresses true excess skin. Some patients have more than one issue and may benefit from a combination approach.
Am I too young for a skin pinch?
Age alone does not determine candidacy, but true lower eyelid skin redundancy is generally more common with aging. Younger patients requesting skin pinch surgery for fine lines or smile wrinkles may have little true excess skin to safely remove.
Can removing lower eyelid skin cause eyelid retraction?
Removing too much skin or removing skin in an inappropriate candidate can create vertical tension on the lower eyelid and contribute to lower eyelid retraction, rounding, scleral show, or ectropion.
Can problems from a skin pinch develop years later?
The face continues to age after surgery. Midface descent and changes in eyelid support can occur over time. For this reason, preserving adequate lower eyelid skin and avoiding unnecessary removal can be particularly important in younger patients.
Considering Under-Eye Rejuvenation in San Diego?
If you are bothered by crepey under-eye skin, wrinkles when smiling, under-eye bags, hollows, or loose lower eyelid skin, the first step is determining what is actually creating the concern.
Once we identify whether the problem is skin quantity, skin quality, muscle movement, volume, or a combination of these factors, we can select a treatment designed for that specific problem.
The goal should not be to chase a procedure because it is trending. The goal should be to choose the right treatment for your anatomy today while respecting how your eyelids and face will continue to age in the years ahead.
Request a consultation at Oculofacial Surgical Arts in San Diego to discuss your under-eye concerns with Jean-Paul Abboud, MD, PhD.
Dr. Abboud is an oculofacial plastic surgeon in San Diego who is an expert on cosmetic blepharoplasty and eyelid surgery. He is board-certified by the American Board of Ophthalmology (AAO) and is a member of the American Society of Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (ASOPRS).
For more information about Blepharoplasty and Cosmetic Eyelid Surgery, or to schedule a consultation with Dr. Abboud for personalized advice on eyelid surgery, call our office at 858.356.2647
Disclaimer: This information is not intended to replace a medical consultation, nor does it constitute a doctor-patient relationship. Each individual’s treatment and/or results will vary, and no guarantee is stated or implied by any photo or statement used on this website.
Comments